Bet Sync

Yankees 2025 Roster Report Cards: Cam Schlittler

Seeing any prospect come up and do well is extremely fun, but there’s something different when it’s a young starting pitcher. A pitcher getting called up and impressing has you dreaming that your team has found someone who could take the ball in key games and playoff series openers and not only give your team a chance, but potentially dominate the opposition.In 2025, Yankees fans got to have those dreams thanks to Cam Schlittler.Grade: A2025 Statistics: 14 games, 73.0 innings, 4-3, 2.96 ERA (138 ERA+), 3.74 FIP, 3.77 xFIP, 27.6 K%, 10.2 BB%, 1.3 fWAR2026 Contract Status: Pre-arbitration eligibleSchlittler was a seventh-round draft pick by the Yankees back in 2022. He was somewhat unheralded, as came out of Northeastern University, which is hardly a college baseball powerhouse. While he’s from Massachusetts, where Northeastern is located, he landed with the Huskies in part because he wasn’t recruited by any of the famous baseball colleges, despite the potential people around him knew he had. A couple good years there got him selected by the Yankees, but a seventh-round pitcher is hardly a sure thing, and definitely falls into the “project” category.Over the next three seasons, Schlittler showcased that potential, even as he went through ups and downs in the minor leagues. After not rating highly on Yankees’ prospect lists early in his MiLB career, by midseason 2025, he was starting to get some love (catching Peter Brody’s eye as early as spring training). With the Yankees also beset by injuries in the rotation, he earned a call-up in early July, shortly after Clarke Schmidt’s season was doomed by Tommy John surgery.Schlittler debuted with 5.1 adequate-but-not-outstanding innings on July 9th against the Mariners, showing the potential with seven strikeouts, but also allowing two home runs. It was a similar story throughout most of his early starts, but once the calendar flipped to mid-August, he began to catch fire. Schlittler put up his longest and first scoreless outing, with 6.2 shutout frames against the Rays on August 20th. He kept the Nationals off the board for six more innings in his next start too. From August 13th though the end of the regular season, Schlittler put up a 2.23 ERA and a 2.62 FIP, recording 60 strikeouts in 48.1 innings.The 24-year-old wrapped up the regular season by allowing just two hits in seven scoreless innings against the Orioles. Going into that game, there was still some amount of debate over who the Yankees should use as the third and fourth starters in their playoff rotation. That game cemented Schlittler’s case that—improbable as it might have been a mere couple months prior, let alone in spring—he had to be one of those pitchers. As we know now, that ended up being a very good choice.Matched up with the Red Sox in the AL Wild Card Series, the Yankees split the first two contests, meaning it all came down to the rookie Schlittler in the decisive Game 3. Even though Boston went with a rookie themselves in Connelly Early, you always have some worries about how someone might respond to the spotlight in their first postseason start. Just for one example, Luis Severino finished third in AL Cy Young Award voting in 2017 and didn’t escape the first inning in his own playoff debut.Facing his hometown team and pitching with some extra motivation thanks to Red Sox fans, Schlittler was completely and utterly dominant in the do-or-die game. In eight innings, Schlittler fanned 12 Boston hitters, as he allowed just five hits — all of which were singles — and no walks, keeping the Red Sox off the scoreboard. Aaron Boone elected to go with the reliable David Bednar for the ninth inning, but you absolutely could’ve made the argument that Schlittler would’ve been the best option in the ninth. Bednar finished the game off without much trouble, sealing the series and cementing Schlittler’s gem as one of the best Yankee starts — in any game of any magnitude — in recent memory.View LinkSchlittler ended up being the losing pitcher in Game 4 of the ALDS as the Yankees were eliminated by the Blue Jays, but he was probably the best Yankee starter in that series as well.Young arms can always be a bit of a crapshoot, health-wise and maintaining performance-wise, so it’s hard to make any definitive judgement right now on what Cam Schlittler’s career will be — he is, in fact, still Rookie of the Year-eligible for 2026. However, you’d certainly be forgiven for having sky-high dreams after what we saw him do after getting called up this year.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial