Bet Sync

The case for Jonathan Gannon vs. Cardinals’ coaching carousel history

It is as predictable as the sun coming up every morning, even if it is behind the clouds.As soon as an NFL team begins a slide back from a previous season or fails to live up to sometimes unrealistic outside expectations, the noise from fans that is even more raucous these days because of social media, masses together to call for the firing of the head coach.The issue is then exacerbated when the owner calling the shots lives in fear that the fans will stop coming to games unless there’s a coaching change.What I invariably laugh at is that as soon as the deed is done, the discussion from the same rowdy fans changes to all the players that need replacing to improve the talent.Well, no kidding. Most of the time, a team loses because of personnel problems (including injuries) that go well beyond what the coach can control.What also happens is that there’s never a guarantee that the new coach will be as good as, much less better than, the one sent away with a nice payday.Which brings us to the 3-10 Arizona Cardinals, a team that has lost seven games by four points or fewer while falling in three lopsided games to their division rivals, two of which have the best records in the NFC. In fact, the 10-3 Los Angeles Rams (plus-152) and Seattle Seahawks (plus-133) have the two best point differentials in the entire league. There’s only other team to reach 100, and that’s the New England Patriots at plus-110.Listening to the emotional reactions to Sunday’s loss to the Rams that called this a crisis, you would think the Cardinals had fallen to a high-school squad. This, of course, was a Cardinals team playing without starters at left guard (Evan Brown), right tackle (Jonah Williams), wide receiver (Marvin Harrison Jr.) and running back (James Conner), as well as the two top backup receivers (Zay Jones and Greg Dortch), two backup running backs (Trey Benson and Emari Demercado) and the top blocking tight end (Tip Reiman).On defense, MIA were promising defensive lineman Walter Nolen III, who has played four games this season, Mike linebacker Mack Wilson Sr. and versatile safety Dadrion Taylor-Demerson. Numerous games have been played with rotating cornerbacks because of preseason injuries to Star Thomas V and Sean Murphy-Bunting as well as missed games during the season for Garrett Williams, Will Johnson and Max Melton.This season is approaching the 2022 season for a never-ending cycle of injuries that resulted in 83 players participating in games with 11 playing all 17 games and only two (Kelvin Beachum and Jalen Thompson) starting all 17.Those numbers don’t even scratch the surface of the bizarre events that began with:The agent-manifesto from Kyler Murray’s agent, who also publicly questioned Michael Bidwill’s commitment to winning. Murray got his deal, but with the infamous “homework clause” that was removed following the furor after it became public. The team then bizarrely said it “was clearly perceived in ways that were never intended.”Murray then suffered a torn ACL in the 11th game of the season and the Cardinals won one of their final six games.Head coach Kliff Kingsbury and general manager Steve Keim received contract extensions announced at the Scouting Combine.Wide receiver DeAndre Hopkins was suspended for the first six games of the season, leading to the acquisition of wide receiver Hollywood Brown for a first-round pick on draft day and then Brown inuring his foot in the game before Hopkins returned.Hold-ins in training camp by tackle D.J. Humphries and linebacker Markus Golden.Running backs coach James Saxon was placed on administrative leave after allegations of a May domestic violence incident became public. Saxon eventually resigned after pleading guilty in October.Cornerback Antonio Hamilton Sr. burned his feet in a cooking accident shortly before the season opener.Defensive lineman J.J. Watt experienced a scare a few days prior to a game when he had his heart shocked back into rhythm, but played.We also must not forget the dismissal of offensive line coach Sean Kugler because of allegations of inappropriate conduct while the team was in Mexico City to play the 49ers in a Monday night game.Speaking of the Oline, Humphries started eight games that season, left guard Justin Pugh five, center Rodney Hudson four and right guard Will Hernandez 13. The Cardinals were 2-2 with Hudson on the field, 2-11 without him.The result, of course, was a setback 4-13 season after being 11-6 in 2021, a season that featured numerous injuries in the second half of the season, including a knee injury for Hopkins and high-ankle sprain for Murray that compromised his performance down the stretch.That led to Kingsbury being fired, despite the extension, and then the arrival of Jonathan Gannon, who along with general manager Monti Ossenfort began a rebuild that started with a 4-13 record, improved to 8-9 in 2024 and now had its hopes shattered by another mind-boggling injury-riddled season.With four games remaining, here are the numbers:75 players participating in games with 21 playing in all 13 and seven starting every game.37 players on the practice squad, including 20 players with no games and another 19 that have been on the practice squad but also played in games.64 different players with at least one special teams snap.25 players currently on injured reserve with 21 placed on IR or reserve/PUP since the cut to 53 players.37 players who have missed 245 games because of injuries. Ten have already missed at least 10 games and four have missed nine.Another reality for those clamoring for change is this franchise’s Bidwillian history of frequently changing coaches, several after a step-back season. In addition to Kingsbury, that happened to Don Coryell, Jim Hanifan and Ken Whisenhunt, who had a little longer leash because of a Super Bowl appearance.The Cardinals were 27-21 in his first three regular seasons that included the Super Bowl and a playoff appearance. However, after Kurt Warner’s retirement, they were 18-30 in the next three seasons with a stunning list of starting quarterbacks (brace yourselves for these memories): Derek Anderson, John Skelton, Max Hall, Kevin Kolb, Ryan Lindley and Brian Hoyer.A Bidwill has owned the team since 1933 and in the ensuing 93 seasons, there have been 39 head coaches, including seven interim leaders and four seasons with co-coaches that include one season with three co-coaches.In the 28 St. Louis seasons, there were 12 head coaches and another 12 in the 38 in Arizona.Hanifan and Whisenhunt are the only head coaches in franchise history to last six seasons and only nine others lasted at least four seasons. Only three have won at least 40 games including the postseason: Bruce Arians 50, Whisenhunt 49 and Coryell 42. Yes, Coryell, whose coaching tenure ended after the 1977 season, is third on the franchise wins list 49 seasons later.The question now is whether Gannon makes it to four. The 10th loss this season makes it 20 Arizona seasons with double-digit losses. Entering this year, there were three with 10 losses, seven with 11, five with 12 and four with 13.Seven in 19 seasons have come since Michael Bidwill became club president in 2007, so that’s an improvement from 13 in the previous 19, but that’s still nothing to crow about. There have been only six winning seasons and three of the 13-loss seasons have come in the last seven seasons. Who knows how this one will end?It’s important to reflect on Bidwill’s words when Kingsbury was fired. He acknowledged the growth of the team in the first three seasons while also noting how “injuries stacked up on us” and that “a lot of breaks didn’t go our way.”However, when asked if he considered giving Kingsbury another year to get things back to where they were, he said there were hopes things would turn around. That was something made almost impossible by the never-ending cavalcade of injuries that, in a fitting end to the season, the team had so many players inactive they played two men short in the season finale against the 49ers.So, what will he decide this time around? Will he succumb to the outside noise, which often doesn’t speak for the majority of fans but is much louder? Or will he see that Ossenfort and Gannon have built a solid structure of quality players and people and move forward with them.And yes, at times there have been some head-scratching decisions, but that’s the case for all coaches. But teams that have most of their best players available and have guys capable of making plays to turn close games into losses, are able to overcome the adversity that hits in games.So, my question for the fire-the-coach crowd, which I asked three years ago, is how can the reality of the current injury-strafed roster be ignored and if you have any confidence Bidwill will get it right this time. Of course, many believe that he did.After the change in 2023, I wrote this, “And even if it looks good at some point, will he be able to weather the storm if there is adversity along the way? He said a few times it was ‘time for a change.’ That phrase has probably been uttered at least 40 times about head coaches in the team’s 103-season history (now 106).“Odds are, unless Bidwill finds a patience pill, they will be said again, and sooner, not particularly later.”Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire’s Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on Spotify, YouTube or Apple podcasts..oembed-frame {width:100%;height:100%;margin:0;border:0;}This article originally appeared on Cards Wire: The case for Jonathan Gannon vs. Cardinals’ coaching carousel history

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial