Bet Sync

Michigan Football Film Study: Examining the offensive woes against Ohio State

Well, that sucked. Two days ago, that team down south claimed its first victory in the storied rivalry in six years. It was decisive, it was dominant, and, in the moment, somehow felt worse than the final score reflected.Ohio State bullied Michigan on both lines of scrimmage, executing with precision on offense and overwhelming physicality on defense. And aside from the false hope briefly provided in the first few minutes, Ohio State flat out kicked Michigan’s ass the entire afternoon.Far from the first time Michigan has had to take its medicine against the Buckeyes, it is a reminder of the fragility of sustained success in the rivalry. Despite recent streakiness, a win over Ohio State would have resulted in Michigan’s first five-game winning streak in the series since the 1920s. But historical context doesn’t help ease pain, as fans are still in the shadow of that letdown performance.So what the hell happened? Why was this team so thoroughly beaten? Who is to blame? There are several areas to point to — both lines of scrimmage, quarterback play, play-calling, coverage busts, you name it — but one glaring issue was the performance on third down.Michigan was horrendous on third down on both sides of the ball. Entering the game, Michigan’s offense had been the best team in the country on the critical down for the month of November and a Top-20 unit the entire season. Against the Buckeyes, Michigan was limited to one conversion on nine attempts; comparatively, Ohio State had more successful third down conversions (10), than Michigan had points.On average, Michigan needed to gain 9.34 yards on these nine attempts, and none were less than 3rd-and-5 (these exclude the two “no plays” that resulted from penalty advancement). Playing behind the sticks is not a recipe for success for any offense, but especially for Michigan’s, whose freshman quarterback never looked younger than he did on Saturday.A week after everything went right on third down, let’s check the tape to see where it went wrong and assess who is to blame for these shortcomings.3rd-and-6; 12-Personnel X-FadeAlready playing with a 3-0 lead, a Jyaire Hill interception on Ohio State’s second offensive play had the Wolverines in business. Three runs later, Michigan was set up with a 1st-and-10 at the Buckeye 11. The Big House was deafening. Sticking to the ground game, Michigan inched closer, setting up a 3rd-and-6 from the seven.A high-percentage run or pass in this instance could have either converted or set up a potential fourth-down attempt. Despite the perceived redundancy of a fifth-straight run here, Ohio State was playing with a light box with coverage rolled to the field. A run attacking the boundary here should have resulted in plus-yardage at minimum. Instead, Michigan went for it all with a low-percentage, barely-used play.Shifting to a 3×1 formation pre-snap, wide receiver Donaven McCulley is isolated to the top of the formation 1-on-1 with no safety. Offensive coordinator Chip Lindsey could have dialed up a slant — something Bryce Underwood and McCulley are both very comfortable executing and would have just had to beat the lurking linebacker — but instead, it’s a fade ball. Underwood never gets his feet set and unnecessarily drifts upon release, causing him to miss his mark high. But even a perfect throw would have difficult for the blanketed McCulley to haul in. After a successful opening drive and an early turnover, Michigan only had a six-point lead. Even in the moment, these minor miscues felt ominous.Blame: Offensive coordinator Chip Lindsey. A feast-or-famine play call Michigan has not shown proficiency in executing is an exercise in futility. Lindsey has been solid this season, but he blinked in the face of pressure in this instance. You could try to force some blame back to Underwood by telling him to wait for Andrew Marsh to come up on his switch-release corner route at the bottom, or Bryson Kuzdzal’s angle route underneath, but slow-developing plays for a true freshman in the low red zone still fall on the play-caller.3rd-and-10; 12-Personnel Y-Stick Variation*Unfortunately, I was unable to find this play on YouTube, but it can be found at the 8:35 mark of the third quarter for anyone with access.Trailing by eight to start the second half, Michigan’s defense forced its first punt of the day. HOORAY! Somehow, the Wolverines still had a pulse despite the offense going into anemic shock without running back Jordan Marshall. This was Michigan’s chance to conjure up some of that rivalry magic it had summoned the previous four years.First play, BANG, 26-yard completion to McCulley on a seam route in triple coverage. Underwood’s best throw of the day. Hurrying to the line, Michigan calls a quick flood concept, and an over-eager Underwood checks it down to his tight end for no gain. If Underwood lets this play develop, he is going to have more options down the field, not to mention the opportunity to put the defense in conflict with his mobility. Alas, second down.The Wolverines go to an RPO next that should be pulled and thrown to Marsh, but the edge’s subtle reaction fools the young quarterback and the ball is given to Kuzdzal for no gain. Again, there should be an audible or call in this situation when the slot receiver is completely uncovered. Alas, third down.Once again in 12-personnel and shifting to a 3×1 formation, this is a great call from Lindsey. The Wolverines are going to put a twist on the classic West Coast Stick concept by running a Wrap route from the No. 2 receiver in the alignment. Ohio State is only rushing three players and dropping eight into coverage, and this concept still creates a massive window for Underwood to get his best receiver the ball.Aligned from the right hash, tight end Zack Marshall is split to the top of the formation (to the field side) with Marsh in the slot and tight end Marlin Klein split tight to the formation. McCulley is split into the boundary at the bottom of the formation.At the top, Marshall is running a clear-out to occupy the corner and potentially the safety. At the bottom, McCulley is going to run a deep curl route. Underneath, Klein is going to sell the block and run a Stick route to pull the hook/curl defenders up and create space in front of the safeties. Marsh is going to run a Wrap route (think an Over or Drag route) right into the vacated zone above Klein. Kuzdzal is going to check-release.Unfortunately, despite no pressure, Underwood’s internal clock is sped up and rushes to his check-down. A sidearm attempt from Underwood to Kuzdzal goes wide for an incompletion, but even if it’s caught, Kuzdzal is going nowhere fast. If Underwood waits a half-second longer, Marsh is going to break wide open in the middle of the defense to keep the drive and game alive.Blame: Quarterback Bryce Underwood. The play call is perfect, the pass protection more than holds up against three rushers, and the receiver comes open right on schedule. However, the moment was a little too big for the true freshman, who was so scared to make a mistake he was incapable of making a play.3rd-and-18; 11-Personnel Flood ConceptAfter a soul-sucking 11-minute drive, Michigan finally got the ball back. Down three scores with nothing to lose, this was a chance for the Wolverines to run its two-minute offense with reckless abandon. A chance to salvage some dignity and get invaluable game reps for the future.The Wolverines come out in a 2×2 formation with 11-personnel. McCulley and fellow wide receiver Channing Goodwin (slot) are split to the bottom with Marsh (split-end) and tight end Deakon Tonielli (H-back) to the top of the formation. Michigan is going to run a Flood Concept. Marsh and Tonielli are going to run a Hank concept, with Marsh running a deep out and Tonielli working into the flat. At the bottom, McCulley (split end) is going to run a deep Out route, Kuzdzal is once again going to check-release into the flat, and Goodwin is going to work a Post route across the field to give Underwood a three-receiver into the boundary. The read here is high to low — Marsh, Goodwin, and then Tonielli. If there is nothing there, Underwood could work back to McCulley, or to Kuzdzal as his last resort.Marsh creates separation, Goodwin runs free, McCulley has space and Kuzdzal is uncovered on the backside. But on 3rd-and-18 with nothing to lose, this ball is checked down to Tonielli for a two-yard gain. There was no pressure or free rushers in Underwood’s face. The quarterback is able to read the field and set his feet. Yet, Michigan’s offense waved the white flag in this moment and surrendered.Before the 2021 season, Jim Harbaugh said, “We’re going to beat Ohio State, or we’re going to die trying.” The worst thing about this game and this play is that neither happened — Michigan went quietly.Blame: Head coach Sherrone Moore. All season long, I have defended Moore and the youth of this team, but the foundation of my support was dependent upon The Game. Moore had earned that right based upon last season’s performance in Columbus, and after the momentum built in College Park last weekend, this team appeared to be on a similar trajectory. But that faith was betrayed on Saturday. Michigan was grossly unprepared. The offense was run like it was 2023 (the same game-planning mistake made against Oklahoma), and Underwood played like he was threatened with castration if he made a mistake. You can’t hand a teenager the keys to the car and scare him with punishment for going one mile over the speed limit, especially in Week 12, after his best performance of the season. The result was Michigan’s worst offensive outing against Ohio State since 2010 and the first time the Wolverines have not scored a touchdown against the Buckeyes since 2007. Both comparative years were the final years in each coach’s — Rich Rodriguez and Lloyd Carr — tenure in Ann Arbor.Furthermore, an alarming trend is beginning to develop on Moore’s watch. Here are the losses by more than two possessions (17 or more) by a Michigan head coach since 1969:Bo Schembechler (1969-89): 3Gary Moeller (1990-94): 2Lloyd Carr (1995-07): 3Rich Rodriguez (2008-10): 11Brady Hoke (2011-14): 5Jim Harbaugh (2015-23): 9Sherrone Moore (2024-): 4Now, this isn’t a call for Moore’s job yet. This team still has a chance for 10 wins in Moore’s second season and the program is littered with young talent. However, when you lose The Game, everything goes under the microscope. And when you get your ass kicked, the pressure and scrutiny are multiplied. Standing firmly on third base, Moore must get closer to home next season, or he could find himself out.

Social media & sharing icons powered by UltimatelySocial